Skip to content
All articles

Myrtle · Technique

Propagation Mastery: Water vs. Soil

Stop rotting your cuttings. We break down the exact node placement and humidity requirements for success.

22 January 2026
Propagation Mastery: Water vs. Soil

By Myrtle

22 January 2026 5 min read

Propagation is the closest thing to magic in the plant world. You take a piece of a living thing, give it the right conditions, and it becomes a whole new organism.

Understanding Nodes

The node is everything. It is the small brown bump on a stem where leaves emerge, and more importantly, where new roots will form. When you take a cutting, always cut just below a node — a cutting without a node cannot root, no matter how long you wait.

Water Propagation

Place your cutting in a clean glass of water with the node submerged. Change the water every few days to prevent bacterial growth. Within two to four weeks, you should see white roots emerging. Wait until they are at least five centimetres long before transferring to soil.

Soil Propagation

For those who prefer going direct, dip the cut end in rooting hormone and plant it in a moist mix of perlite and vermiculite. Keep the humidity high — a clear plastic bag over the pot works as a makeshift greenhouse. You will know it has rooted when you feel resistance when gently tugging the stem.

Which Method Wins?

Water propagation lets you watch the roots develop, which is satisfying and educational. Soil propagation produces roots that are already adapted to growing in soil, so the transition shock is minimal. Both work — choose whichever brings you more joy.